michaels Camera Hire

Search

BUY
SECOND HAND
CONTACT CHAT
🌐 BOOK ONLINE 24/7 📅 OPEN BY APPOINTMENT ☎️ (03) 9088 0211

Comparing Flash and Natural Light: Simple Product Photography (Part 3)

Pro­duc­ing fan­tas­tic prod­uct pho­tos is es­sen­tial for any small busi­ness. In the era of so­cial me­dia and the in­ter­net, pho­tos are of­ten the first in­ter­ac­tion that cus­tomers will have with your prod­ucts and that can mean the dif­fer­ence be­tween cus­tomers stop­ping to buy or scrolling onto the next thing…

In the pre­vi­ous two ar­ti­cles we’ve talked about how to set up a prod­uct shoot us­ing two sim­ple se­tups: nat­ur­al light and a sin­gle flash. How­ev­er, which set­up pro­duces the best re­sults? The an­swer to that ques­tion de­pends on how much time and mon­ey you want to put into your pho­tographs and whether you’re com­fort­able edit­ing your pho­tographs af­ter they’re cap­tured.

For this se­ries we cap­tured two pho­tos of a Sony a7S III, one with nat­ur­al light and one with a flash. Our aim was to cre­ate a set­up that could be repli­cat­ed by some­one with lit­tle or no pho­to­graph­ic ex­pe­ri­ence to pro­duce an im­age with a clean, even­ly lit back­ground that could be used for ecom­merce. We want­ed to pro­duce the best re­sult in-cam­era such that no edit­ing would need to be done in post-pro­duc­tion (al­though we’ll talk about this more lat­er). The re­sult­ing im­ages, straight from the cam­era with­out any al­ter­ation, are found be­low:

Us­ing nat­ur­al light
The prod­uct in this set­up looks washed out, a re­sult of try­ing to push the ex­po­sure to achieve a white back­ground. While we could have dark­ened the im­age to make the blacks a bit rich­er, we’d end up with a dull grey back­ground by do­ing so. How­ev­er, the di­rec­tion of the light­ing does look ac­cept­able and cre­ates some depth and con­trast amongst the de­tails of the cam­era. There is a slight­ly cool tint to the front of the prod­uct and a warm tint to the back of it, caused by a change in the colour of the light as it was re­flect­ed around the room.

Us­ing flash
The prod­uct in this set­up looks cor­rect­ly ex­posed and the blacks look, well, black. We’re see­ing a nice, even light across the cam­era how­ev­er even with the bounce cards the front is still a lit­tle dark. If we had some larg­er, thick­er card­board this may have helped but cur­rent­ly the front of the prod­uct doesn’t have as much ‘pop’ as the side light­ing of the nat­ur­al light im­age. The colours of the prod­uct look ac­cu­rate and nat­ur­al, with no dis­cernible tint.

Analysing the Back­ground

Analysing the back­ground us­ing nat­ur­al light
Here we see the same ver­sion of the nat­ur­al light pho­to four times. While the back­ground looks okay as a sin­gle im­age, there is quite a lot of falloff in the back­ground of this im­age. This be­comes par­tic­u­lar­ly ob­vi­ous when arranged into a grid, such as you’d find on web stores or In­sta­gram. This in­con­sis­ten­cy in the lay­out gives the im­ages an am­a­teur­ish feel.

Analysing the back­ground us­ing flash
Here we see the same ver­sion of the flash pho­to four times. The back­ground is al­most per­fect­ly even, with some slight falloff from top to bot­tom. The im­ages arranged as a grid ap­pear much more con­sis­tent than their nat­ur­al light coun­ter­parts and present a more co­he­sive set of prod­ucts.

The clear win­ner here is the flash set­up, which pro­vides a clean and con­sis­tent look with min­i­mal ef­fort. What’s more, this look can be per­fect­ly repli­cat­ed time and time again for any num­ber of prod­ucts, and can be set up months or days down the track and still achieve the same look.

Edit­ing

The se­tups de­scribed in these ar­ti­cles were de­signed in a way that some­one with lit­tle to no pho­tog­ra­phy ex­pe­ri­ence could cap­ture nice look­ing pho­tos of their prod­ucts. How­ev­er, edit­ing goes hand in hand with pho­tog­ra­phy and many pro­fes­sion­al pho­tog­ra­phers will do some lev­el of post-pro­cess­ing to their im­ages af­ter they’re cap­tured. So, what hap­pens if we edit the above two pho­tos? The an­swer to which is best be­comes a lit­tle less clear cut. Here are the pho­tos af­ter some ba­sic prod­uct edit­ing, in­clud­ing: con­trast and ex­po­sure ad­just­ment, white bal­ance cor­rec­tion, deep etch­ing and crop­ping. Each im­age has had the same kinds of ad­just­ments, though in dif­fer­ing amounts.

The nat­ur­al light pho­to ar­guably looks bet­ter! There is still some in­con­sis­ten­cies with the colour, how­ev­er the im­age has more ‘pop’ than its over­head flash coun­ter­part and the deep etch­ing has re­moved any in­con­sis­ten­cies with the back­ground. The rea­son for this is the side light­ing, which is bring­ing out more con­trast in places like the text on the body cap.

So does this mean nat­ur­al light­ing is bet­ter if you are want­i­ng to edit? Well, the an­swer to that is still no. The big draw­back of nat­ur­al light is the in­con­sis­ten­cy be­tween ini­tial im­ages, so while things have worked well for one pho­to, over many pho­tos the edit­ing process be­comes con­vo­lut­ed and te­dious.

It is also easy to mim­ic the side light­ing of the nat­ur­al light im­age by sim­ply mov­ing the flash to the side of the cam­era, rather than above it. The rea­son the light was first put above was so that the back­ground was even­ly il­lu­mi­nat­ed, how­ev­er if we are re­mov­ing this any­way then we can sim­ply move the flash to the side of the prod­uct. This means we get all the ben­e­fits of us­ing flash while also cre­at­ing in­ter­est­ing light­ing.

Con­clu­sion

The best light­ing set­up for you and your prod­ucts will de­pend­ing on your skillset, bud­get and how much time you are will­ing to put into edit­ing. If we were to rank the se­tups cov­ered in these ar­ti­cles, the best method would be:

  • Us­ing flash from the side if you are edit­ing your im­ages
  • Us­ing flash from above if you don’t want to edit your im­ages
  • Us­ing nat­ur­al light and edit­ing if you are work­ing on a tight bud­get

If you are still un­sure what set­up will be best for you, or want more ad­vice on the right equip­ment to hire for a prod­uct shoot get in touch.

Canon, Prod­uct Pho­tog­ra­phy, Nat­ur­al Light, Dif­fuser, Re­flec­tor, White Back­ground